Capillary electrophoresis (CE) competes with several separations techniques in the laboratory, including high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), ultrahigh-pressure liquid chromatography (UHPLC), and ion chromatography (IC). Participants in this Tech Forum are LCGC Editorial Advisory Board members Mary Ellen McNally of DuPont Crop Protection and Kevin Altria of GlaxoSmithKline.
Capillary electrophoresis (CE) competes with several separations techniques in the laboratory, including high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), ultrahigh-pressure liquid chromatography (UHPLC), and ion chromatography (IC). Participants in this Tech Forum are LCGC Editorial Advisory Board members Mary Ellen McNally of DuPont Crop Protection and Kevin Altria of GlaxoSmithKline.
For large molecules that carry a charge, CE is often the best technology to employ. Can you comment on the ruggedness of CE and how it might affect its widespread application? What are the best applications to date for CE that are widely employed and constitute the base support or funding for the technology?
McNally: We have worked very diligently over the years to find the applications where CE is a better answer than HPLC and then later UHPLC. We have found a few minor examples but nothing that could support long term use and application in a routine laboratory. Applications in a research environment still show up periodically, so analytical chemists would be wise to have the technology in their tool-box of techniques to solve problems.
Altria: Kit-based separations and bespoke instruments have standardized separations and greatly assisted in eliminating sources of variance that has improved method performance and robustness. Recently 12 laboratories from 10 independent pharma companies highlighted the robustness of CE methods when they used a capillary isoelectric focusing (cIEF) method to both accurately and precisely (RSD values below 1%) determine the apparent pI (isoelectric point) and charge variant distribution of a monoclonal antibody (1). A previous successful interlaboratory exercise covering a range of pharma companies and regulatory bodies used CE to confirm the molecular weight of proteins and to evaluate charge heterogeneity and purity (2). Relative migration times of less than 2% RSD were obtained across the labs. Quantification of the rMAB sample components was also highly comparable across the organizations.
CE analysis of large molecules is now a standard and well-established front-line approach within pharma companies involved in developing and marketing biopharmaceutics. CE methods are included in regulatory submissions and are in routine use in QA laboratories to release batches of product.
What are the best applications to date for CE that are widely employed and constitute the base support or funding for the technology?
Altria: The analysis of biopharmaceuticals is a clear application area. CE is also widely employed in drug discovery activities where standard methods can be used to experimentally determine solubilities (log P) and pKa values — often using multiplex CE instruments to gain high throughput. Standard ion analysis methods for inorganic anions (3) or metal ions (4) using kits are also popular. The most popular application is chiral analysis where method development can be very rapid generating robust methods allowing quantification of 0.1% of the undesired enantiomer.
CE has been around for quite a while and has not appeared to "take-off" as a general purpose instrumentation tool. Why is that?
McNally: The "take off" for a technology really happens when the industrial users move instrumentation to the routine. And as I mentioned above that has not happened for us at DuPont very often. There are a couple of hurdles: first, capital investment of the new instrumentation, in this case CE, at the routine laboratory, second, training of personnel in CE, and third, maintaining the capability at the routine laboratory.
So we make every effort to only put new technology in to the routine environment, when what we already have there will absolutely not work. CE competes with HPLC, UHPLC, and IC, all very well established and versatile techniques.
Altria: CE encountered a formidable competitor in the form of HPLC! Labs were well equipped with HPLC equipment and trained staff who could operate equipment and run methods. CE equipment did suffer from lack of sensitivity and methods were not always developed with robustness in mind – these have both improved with technology and knowledge advances. CE has displaced HPLC and some other techniques in specific applications but I don’t think will take over the workhorse activities of assay and impurity determinations that continue to be performed by HPLC.
Do you have examples where CE can accomplish a separation that HPLC cannot?
McNally: We have used CE to replace IC for ion analysis only if the facility we are using does not have an IC system.
Not a very good example for your cause. And we prefer that the routine lab puts IC in place so extensive method transfer does not have to take place between two facilities that are using two different techniques
Altria: The main one would be chiral analysis. There were often examples where a chemist would come along with a sample of a racemic compound and say they had spent several weeks trying to develop a chiral separation. They were often amazed to receive an email a couple of hours later with a CE separation, generally with standard cyclodextrin-based electrolytes.
References
(1) O. Salas-Solano et al., Chromatographia, 73, 1137–1144 (2011).
(2) B. Nunnally et al., Chromatographia, 64, 359–368 (2006).
(3) K.D. Altria, LCGC Europe, 24(1), 32–36 (2011).
(4) K.D. Altria, LCGC Europe, 23(11), 543–545 (2010).
Characterization and Assessment of Effects of Drying Temperature on Edible Mushrooms with HS-GC–MS
September 6th 2024To gain insight into the effect of drying temperature on its composition, headspace solid-phase microextraction-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (HS-SPME-GC–MS) was used for the identification of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) of 86 mushroom samples that were divided into five groups and dried at different temperatures.
Modern HPLC Strategies: Improving Retention and Peak Shape for Basic Analytes
August 16th 2024In high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), it is common for bases and unreacted ionized silanols on silica-based columns to cause irreproducible retention, broad peaks, and peak tailing when working with basic analytes. David S. Bell, Lead Consultant at ASKkPrime LLC offers innovative HPLC strategies that can help mitigate such issues.
Real-Time Measurement of EPA Regulated HON Compounds and Environmental Pollutants Using SIFT-MS
September 6th 2024This application note describes the determination of method detection limits (MDLs) for the newly regulated HON (Hazardous Organic NESHAP) compounds, which validate SIFT-MS as an effective solution for measuring these toxic VOCs and other environmental pollutants in ambient air, whether at the fence line or in a mobile setting.